 |
Canada's Hot Real Estate Story Cools
Except for Montreal, prices drop and
sales plunge.
Canadian Real Estate
Prices, Sales and Inventory Data June 2010
The Plunge-O-Meter has
kicked back into gear after a wonderful rally out of the January-February
2009 pit of gloom. Now we're post HST, and much later after the historic
run up with the commodity boom that
ignited like a roman candle in the spring of 2004, and then zoomed away in
the spring of 2005. My view is that unless the government of the day can
goose the market (free down payments? ability to write off mortgage
interest on personal residence? tax reduction on investment income?), we
will revisit the prices of the Spring of 2005. But first we have to see
what the next sell off does to demand. In case you have forgotten the
depth and velocity of the last market reversal when Canadian real estate
prices plunged in 2007-2008 (chart);
equity vanished as follows:
-
Average
Vancouver SFD lost $122,900, down 15.9% in 8 months,
-
Average
Calgary SFD lost $92,499, down 18.3% in 18 months,
-
Average
Edmonton SFD lost $78,719, down 18.5% in 21 months,
-
Average
Toronto SFD lost $55,055, down 13.8% in 9 months,
-
Average Ottawa
Residence lost $25,664, down 8.6% in 6 months and
-
Median
Montreal SFD lost $6,000, down 2.6% in 6 months
So that's the first test... will prices find
support at the levels set in the spring of 2009? It's a different world
now than it was in 2007-2009. The days of
historically low interest rates are numbered and the cost of debt is being
re-priced. Calculate your real net worth.
|
|
| |
The CANADIAN REAL ESTATE PLUNGE-O-METER & PRICE
SUPPORT FORECASTER tracks the dollar and percentage losses from the peak
and projects when prices might find support. Housing price data are average Single Family
Dwellings* except
Ottawa which are Combined
Residential (Single Family, Multi Family and Condos).
Montreal data changed from
average to median at March 2007) |
|
|
~ |
| |
|
*SFD Prices |
Vancouver |
Calgary |
Edmonton |
Toronto |
Ottawa |
Montreal |
|
Prices at Peak |
$818,403 |
$505,920 |
$426,028 |
$446,593 |
$333,408 |
$260,000 |
|
Peak Price Date |
Apr-2010 |
Jul-2007 |
May-2007 |
May-2010 |
May-2010 |
Jun-2010 |
|
Prices Now |
$795,025 |
$481,964 |
$391,497 |
$435,034 |
$326,572 |
$260,000 |
|
Prices Now Date |
Jun-2010 |
Jun-2010 |
Jun-2010 |
Jun-2010 |
Jun-2010 |
Jun-2010 |
|
Months since Peak |
2 |
35 |
37 |
1 |
1 |
0 |
|
$ Plunge from Peak |
-$23,378 |
-$23,956 |
-$34,531 |
-$11,559 |
-$6,836 |
$0 |
|
$ Plunge per Year |
-$139,882 |
-$8,210 |
-$11,193 |
-$140,631 |
-$83,170 |
$0 |
|
% Plunge from Peak |
-2.9% |
-4.7% |
-8.1% |
-2.6% |
-2.1% |
0.0% |
|
% Plunge per Year |
-17.1% |
-1.6% |
-2.6% |
-31.5% |
-24.9% |
0.0% |
|
Deflation per Month |
$11,657 |
$684 |
$933 |
$11,719 |
$6,931 |
$0 |
|
**Price Support Target |
$503,141 |
$276,776 |
$216,187 |
$330,545 |
$248,865 |
$215,407 |
|
Months Until Target |
25 |
300 |
188 |
9 |
11 |
? |
|
Price Support Date |
Jul-2012 |
Jun-2035 |
Feb-2026 |
Mar-2011 |
Jun-2011 |
? |
|
|
|
~ |
| |
|
|
The price support target** in the table above represents what
average Single Family house prices across
Canada were in March 2005 (Ottawa are combined residential) which marked the beginning of a
5 year
period of ardent speculation in Canadian real estate. Look at the
price chart and see that there was a
4-6 month plateau period while buyers and sellers twitched
like a herd. When the credit spreads narrowed and the
yield curve began its journey towards
inversion, the stampede began.
|
|
| |
NOTE WORTHY:
Is it possible to have a system of taxation which is simple, efficient,
progressive, and revenue neutral replacing all existing taxes: personal,
corporate, provincial, fuel, capital gains, estate, excise and sales taxes
with no filing of tax returns, no lobbying and no special deductions? As
it turns out, Yes.
By capitalizing on financial data processing technology, it is possible to
create a tax code for the 21st century; one that is astonishingly easy for
all citizens to understand, that is easy to administer and to comply with
because it eliminates the need to file tax or information returns. The
system, developed by University of Wisconsin Professor of Economics Edgar
L. Feige, is known as the APT or Automated Payments Transaction Tax.
Dr. Feige would levy a toll (based on U.S. data from
2005) of just 0.6 percent on every electronic financial transaction. The
fee would be split by payer and payee in any transaction, meaning you
would pay 0.3 percent whenever you spent or received money. Someone
spending $50,000 a year would pay just $150 in "tax", without any need to
file a return. A $100 restaurant bill would yield a $0.60 fee split 50/50
between the restaurant and the patron.
Most of the value of transactions in a modern economy consists of
financial dealings: sales of stocks, bonds, currency exchanges, and
transactions at tens of thousands of point of sale terminals.
Implementation of this elegant and simple idea in
Canada would allow Canadians to create an original, authentic social
organization that would eventually be copied by all other nations;
unless of course the incumbents are afraid of change and would rather cling to their failed state agenda.
Let's apply the power of the internet to get this
Automated Payments Transaction Tax idea into the mainstream and into
application. Canadians, write your
Member of Parliament.
AND THIS JUST IN: What will
be the "liquidity event" ie: the credit event that causes a severe melt
down (or melt up!) in the global equity and commodity markets this year,
2010? Answer: It could be BP.
Read this review by Gordon Long (presently involved
in private equity placements internationally along with proprietary
trading involving the development and application of Chaos Theory and
Mandelbrot Generator algorithms.)
http://www.safehaven.com/article/17352/sultans-of-swap-bp-potentially-more-devastating-than-lehman
It's well worth the read... Gordon argues that the BP
Gulf Disaster could be the credit event that causes:
"Deleveraging associated with BP may be the event
that triggers the $5T Quantitative Easing spike we have been warning about
for some time now. It will be needed to complete the final process of
manufacturing of a Minsky Melt-up to avoid the looming pension,
entitlement and US state financial crisis. The ability of the government
to achieve this is anything but certain. However, we need to expect the
unexpected and watch out for fat tails to trip over."
Melt-up:
http://mises.org/daily/2787
|
|
|